Research impact & public engagement: what funders expect
From NSF broader impacts and NIH research dissemination to UKRI public engagement and CIHR knowledge translation, funders want research to make a difference. Here's how to plan a useful, realistic approach without turning it into a box-ticking exercise.
Impact, engagement and dissemination aren't identical.
These terms often appear together in grant applications and research reporting. They're connected, but treating them as interchangeable makes for a weak plan.
Getting findings out
Making research available to people who might use it: publications, conferences, websites, videos, policy briefs and other channels.
Connecting with people
Communicating and, importantly, listening. This might mean dialogue, co-design, patient involvement, school activities or community discussions.
Making a difference
The change or benefit that research contributes to, such as better understanding, practice, policy, skills, services or environmental outcomes.
Simple example: Publishing an animation is dissemination. Discussing it with local educators is engagement. Evidence that the material helped change teaching practice could contribute to an impact claim. They are different stages, not interchangeable proof.
The term broader impacts has a particular meaning at the US National Science Foundation (NSF). Elsewhere, you may encounter knowledge translation, public involvement, pathways to impact or communication, dissemination and exploitation. The practical question is similar: who could benefit, and what credible steps might help that happen?
How major research funders approach it
These examples come from official guidance. They are not a claim that every grant requires the same engagement plan or that commissioning an animation meets a funding condition.
Broader Impacts
The NSF reviews proposals against Intellectual Merit and Broader Impacts. The latter considers the potential to benefit society and advance desired outcomes.
What that means: explain why the benefit matters, how the activity will work, whether the team can deliver it and how success will be assessed. Broader impacts may come from the research itself, not only outreach.
NSF merit-review criteria ↗Dissemination and public outcomes
The NIH does not apply NSF's universal Broader Impacts criterion. Requirements differ by funding opportunity and award.
What that means: NIH progress reports ask how results were disseminated to communities of interest, and final project-outcomes summaries must be understandable to the general public. Some programmes place particular emphasis on dissemination and implementation research.
NIH reporting requirements ↗Public engagement and impact
UK Research and Innovation encourages researchers to consider public engagement from the beginning and cost relevant activities in funding proposals. Expectations vary by research council and call.
What that means: identify who should be involved, include listening and dialogue where appropriate, address accessibility and explain what success would look like. UKRI distinguishes engagement from impact, while recognising engagement as one route to impact.
UKRI public-engagement guidance ↗Knowledge Translation (KT)
The Canadian Institutes of Health Research distinguishes end-of-grant KT from integrated KT, where knowledge users are engaged during the research process.
What that means: match the activity to the intended knowledge users, such as clinicians, patients, policymakers or other researchers. CIHR's Project Grant guidance describes dissemination costs as eligible, but actual spending still needs to meet award and institutional rules.
CIHR knowledge-translation guidance ↗Communication, dissemination and exploitation
Horizon Europe generally expects applicants to outline planned communication, dissemination and exploitation activities, unless a work programme states otherwise. Funded projects have further planning and reporting obligations.
What that means: distinguish raising awareness of the project, making results available to relevant audiences and enabling results to be used. Plan for project-specific visibility, access and acknowledgement requirements.
Horizon Europe Programme Guide ↗Check the actual call. An R01, NSF research grant, UKRI council award, CIHR project grant and Horizon Europe consortium will not have identical instructions. Read the current funding opportunity, application guide, eligible-cost rules and reporting conditions before finalising a plan or budget.
A six-step plan that works across disciplines
Forget the generic promise to “raise awareness”. Use these six questions to build a plan your research team can actually deliver.
What should change?
Understanding, skills, decisions, conversations, professional practice or access to reliable information?
For whom?
Name the relevant group: patients, teachers, policymakers, practitioners, communities or industry.
What will you do?
Choose a format suited to their needs: a briefing, workshop, co-designed resource, animation or discussion.
Who can help?
Involve people who know the audience. Agree responsibilities rather than assuming they will share your output.
What will it take?
Plan staff time, translation, captioning, accessibility, production, delivery and evaluation as appropriate.
How will you know?
Track distribution, feedback, learning, adoption or other outcomes matched to your actual objective.
Match the activity to the people
Patient group
Co-develop a plain-language explanation, then ask patients whether the information answers their practical questions.
Community partner
Use a short visual explanation to support a local discussion, then record feedback and follow-up actions.
Industry audience
Show how a proposed method works, gather technical questions and document any subsequent use or collaboration.
Not every project needs an animation or a public event. Choose the approach that helps the intended users understand, discuss or apply the research.
Turn “we'll share our findings” into a real plan
Imagine a team studying how microorganisms could remove pollutants from waterways. It wants local environmental groups and educators to understand the research, without overselling early-stage findings.
“We will communicate our results widely.”
No named audience, no clear method, no partner, no timetable and no way to judge whether the information was useful.
Define the activity and outcome
Produce an accessible explanation with an education partner, use it in two discussions, and evaluate clarity, questions raised and requests for reuse.
Illustrative proposal wording
Illustrative wording only. Not a funded case study or a template endorsed by NSF, NIH, UKRI, CIHR or the European Commission. Adapt to your project and the call.
Measure more than how many people saw it
Reach matters, but an impression isn't the same as understanding, and understanding isn't necessarily the same as behaviour change. Pick evidence that matches the claim you want to make.
| What you want to show | What to collect | What it does — and doesn't — prove |
|---|---|---|
| Reach | Views, unique viewers, event attendance, relevant partner distribution. | Shows exposure, not necessarily learning or impact. |
| Understanding | Brief learning checks, questions, qualitative feedback and comprehension tests. | Can support a claim that the material helped people understand the topic. |
| Engagement | Discussion participation, partner feedback, repeat involvement. | Indicates active interaction, but not automatically long-term change. |
| Use or adoption | Requests for reuse, classroom integration, documented service or practice changes. | Provides stronger evidence of application; attribution to research may still need care. |
On a phone? Swipe sideways to see the full table.
Make the evidence proportionate. A short educational resource may reasonably use targeted user feedback; a long-term intervention intended to change professional practice may require a more rigorous evaluation. Keep the underlying evidence, not just a headline number.
When is scientific animation worth including?
A video is useful when it explains something your audience would otherwise struggle to picture or provides a reliable resource that can be reused in teaching, briefings and engagement. It should support an objective, not become the objective.
Explain
Make hidden processes, methods, evidence or relationships easier to follow without removing important scientific caveats.
Adapt
Build an accurate, audience-appropriate starting point for public talks, stakeholder discussions or classroom use.
Reuse
Give researchers and their partners an asset they can link from project pages, present and circulate as relevant.
SciTube offers Video Lite at £980 (up to two minutes), Animation Classic at £2,300 (approximately three minutes of bespoke 2D) and Animation Plus at £4,800 (up to 3.5 minutes with enhanced production elements). These are package totals, not per-minute prices. Production, publication and standard dissemination are included. See the detailed scientific-animation cost guide.
Can you budget for it? Potentially, where the communication work is relevant and the cost is permitted, justified and approved under your grant and institutional rules. A purchased animation does not, by itself, satisfy a funding requirement or increase the likelihood of award.
For other practical approaches, read why public engagement matters for research funding and the difference between scholarly publishing and public communication.
Research impact and engagement FAQs
Does every research grant require a public-engagement plan?
No. Funders use different criteria, and even opportunities within the same funder can vary. Check the call before adding activities or costs.
Is NSF broader impacts the same as UKRI research impact?
No. Broader Impacts is a formal NSF merit-review criterion. UKRI has its own guidance on public engagement and impact, with requirements that vary by council and opportunity. The aims may overlap, but the frameworks are not interchangeable.
Does NIH require a broader-impacts statement?
NIH generally does not use the NSF Broader Impacts criterion. Its applications, award terms and progress reporting have their own requirements. The NIH RPPR includes dissemination to communities of interest and a public-facing project outcomes summary.
What does CIHR mean by knowledge translation?
CIHR uses KT to describe activities helping research findings reach and be used by appropriate knowledge users. End-of-grant KT focuses on communicating results; integrated KT involves relevant users throughout the research process.
Are video views evidence of research impact?
They can show reach. For understanding, engagement or practical benefit, collect relevant feedback or evidence of use. Avoid presenting view counts alone as proof of societal change.
Can science communication be included in a grant budget?
Often, if it is appropriate for the project and the call permits the expense. That is not universal. Budget staff time, accessibility, production and assessment transparently, and confirm allowability with the institution or funder.